On the whole Anne Rice thingy...
Sep. 23rd, 2004 03:22 pmFor years, I've still counted myself an Anne Rice fan. Not going to be a hypocrite here; I loved The Vampire Lestat (though not Interview With a Vampire--Louis was such a whiner) and Queen of the Damned, and found The Witching Hour enthralling. And then there are the Beauty books; ye gods, I don't think I would be a smut writer if it hadn't been for those. I read 'em in college, and it was one of those life epiphanies: people write this and people read this and, yes, people DO like this, just like me. Kinky, explicit, and just so good.
It's telling that I can't really remember what happened in a good percentage of her other Lestat and Mayfair Witches books, but I didn't think they were pieces of s**t--just mediocre. Most of them are on my shelf; I think I gave up around Pandora, deciding that the mediocrity had at last lost me, oh well.
I'd heard she's rejected editing for a number of years, which has made me say, "And it shows." I was also aware that she doesn't want fanfiction written of her universes, which I have always thought a pretentious attitude--you can't control people's creativity or fantasies, and as long as they're not making money off your creation, why should you care?
But for sheer gasket-blowing...I swear, I was all on the "Wait, wait, are we SURE this is really her?" side of things, because the sheer vitriol...my god. I've been waiting for the news item from Rice's agent refuting that that was her posting. Hasn't happened. I guess I'm the naïve one.
Does it stop me from being an Anne Rice fan?
Well, let me put it this way. People don't usually say, "I'm a Laurence Olivier movie fan." Or, "I'm a JK Rowling book fan." Or, to carry the thing ad nauseum, a Tori Amos song fan, or a Georgia O'Keefe picture fan, etc. They just say, "I'm a (person) fan." It's only when that person starts being offensive as a person that those qualifications come in--I'm a fan of Orson Scott Card's fiction; I'm a fan of Eminem's music.
But it's an odd, unconventional phrasing. When I used to say, "I'm an Anne Rice fan," did that mean I loved the lady herself? No, of course not; I didn't know her from Fried Rice. But everyone knew what I meant.
So, no, there will be no back-turning on books I know and love just because the lady's gone postal. Anyone want to come in here and sigh over how much fun Lestat was as The Brat Prince, and how much we wanted to be Rowan Mayfair, and how effing sexy the Tristan/Nicolas stuff was, please come right in, I have hot cider and pie waiting.
It's telling that I can't really remember what happened in a good percentage of her other Lestat and Mayfair Witches books, but I didn't think they were pieces of s**t--just mediocre. Most of them are on my shelf; I think I gave up around Pandora, deciding that the mediocrity had at last lost me, oh well.
I'd heard she's rejected editing for a number of years, which has made me say, "And it shows." I was also aware that she doesn't want fanfiction written of her universes, which I have always thought a pretentious attitude--you can't control people's creativity or fantasies, and as long as they're not making money off your creation, why should you care?
But for sheer gasket-blowing...I swear, I was all on the "Wait, wait, are we SURE this is really her?" side of things, because the sheer vitriol...my god. I've been waiting for the news item from Rice's agent refuting that that was her posting. Hasn't happened. I guess I'm the naïve one.
Does it stop me from being an Anne Rice fan?
Well, let me put it this way. People don't usually say, "I'm a Laurence Olivier movie fan." Or, "I'm a JK Rowling book fan." Or, to carry the thing ad nauseum, a Tori Amos song fan, or a Georgia O'Keefe picture fan, etc. They just say, "I'm a (person) fan." It's only when that person starts being offensive as a person that those qualifications come in--I'm a fan of Orson Scott Card's fiction; I'm a fan of Eminem's music.
But it's an odd, unconventional phrasing. When I used to say, "I'm an Anne Rice fan," did that mean I loved the lady herself? No, of course not; I didn't know her from Fried Rice. But everyone knew what I meant.
So, no, there will be no back-turning on books I know and love just because the lady's gone postal. Anyone want to come in here and sigh over how much fun Lestat was as The Brat Prince, and how much we wanted to be Rowan Mayfair, and how effing sexy the Tristan/Nicolas stuff was, please come right in, I have hot cider and pie waiting.
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 12:32 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 12:35 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:07 pm (UTC)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 12:39 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 12:41 pm (UTC)*Grabs a piece of pie...*
Date: 2004-09-23 12:49 pm (UTC)Well... I just expounded on this subject to a very good friend of mine, and so need to catch my breath.
Okay... here goes!
"Cry to Heaven" is by far my favorite book by her. To be honest, I'd always thought she was pretentious, but back when I was still reading her stuff with what could be called regularity, I thought reading pretentious authors was fun, kind of like the people who think that blonds are sexy until one day, they wake up and discover that their tastes run to darker hair, you know?
Yes, I thought the man on man sex in the Beauty books was just... hot as all hell, and I still do, but I have found that even while I thought her stuff was fun, rereading it was almost impossible. I, too, was completely captivated by "The Witching Hour." The history, and the many details she wove into its structure were truly astounding, especially concerning the early history of New Orleans. Most of that was sstuff you generally don't find on the many tours you could take of the city. If nothing else, you can truly tell, as a reader, how much she utterly adores the place.
I was very irritated by her latest fit, though. I'm not going to sit here and say that she disappointed me, and why did she have to go and act that way, because I thought she was better than that, because damn it, she's human, after all, but still, she could have found a much subtler way to sayy all that. And, what the hell was all that about interrogating the text? What? You interrogate a person, not a text! I read books like the kind she writes with a mind to escape the real world, not interrogate, or analyze, or mull over the damned text! I spent three years of my life doing that almost constantly to everything I read, and don't have a damn job for all my hard work, which proves that I probably wasted my time.
Anyway, no, I probably won't stop liking what I do like of her books, I just don't think I'll invest in anything new she chooses to write. Being blind, I was buying the books on audio cassette, and that's expensive, let me tell you! I had a tradition going; every time one of her books would come out, I'd go to the nearest book store within seven days of its arrival, and start harping on the people behind the counter for my audio copy. Several book store managers got to know me quite well, and one of them even had a copy of each new book set out for me within a day of its release to audio format. Wait till he hears that I'll no longer be buying anything more of hers! He's going to be disappointed, I'm sure. :-) Ah well, I expect he'll find something to comfort him from the grievous loss of my presence. :-)
Re: *Grabs a piece of pie...*
Date: 2004-09-23 01:18 pm (UTC)Anne Rice is on my list of authors I won't give royalties to by buying her books. The others are Mercedes Lackey, Poppy Z. Brite, and Laurell K. Hamilton.
Re: *Grabs a piece of pie...*
From:Re: *Grabs a piece of pie...*
From:Re: *Grabs a piece of pie...*
From:Re: *Grabs a piece of pie...*
From:no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 12:52 pm (UTC)I haven't read any of her books myself, but I still want to do so, sometime. Sure, it seems she's gone crazy, and I believe people when they say most (if not all) of her writing is mediocre or even bad, but I want to be able to judge for myself, so.. *shrugs*.
¹
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 01:24 pm (UTC)I haven't really enjoyed her last several books all that much. Yes, she does need an editor. When you read a sentence ten times and still can't figure out what the hell the author is trying to say, because the sentence far too long and hideously structured, yes, you do need and editor. I haven't bought any of her books in a long time, though. That's what the public library is for. ;)
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 01:26 pm (UTC)While I haven't read the Beauty books in years and years, they did have a really big impact on me, similar to the one you described. When I saw them in the bookstore, I tried to sneak them out. (No, not without paying, but with as few people seeing me with them as possible.) It wasn't until I got them home that it hit me: If there were books being written and published about this kink, then there must be many people who like it! Maybe it's even "okay"!
So while I think she's a twit if the editing thing is true, I owe her a thanks for the Beauty series.
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 05:41 pm (UTC)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 01:37 pm (UTC)*is a fan of the Vampire Chronicles and has been very afraid to admit it recently*
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 01:43 pm (UTC)I am a shameless Lestat fan, though I must admit my favourite Vampire is, hands down, Gabrielle. Theirloveissoincestous.
Also, I know I'm of a minority here, but I loved Blood and Gold.
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 01:47 pm (UTC)As for her as a person... >_< Her trying to forbid fanfiction and telling her fans to boycott movies annoyed the hell out of me. I though she was a self-centered, stupid, little bint.
After that lovely little paragraph of doom I am even more certain of that... But I'd like to add delusion, egoism, hypocrisy and megalomania to her list of symptoms... -_-'''
(Sorry... But I just can't help it...)
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 01:55 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:37 pm (UTC)(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:48 pm (UTC)As for the whole "I'm a fan of the ART, not the ARTIST", I have to say that my exception is Linkin Park, because I like what they say and I like their goofy public personae. How can you not love someone who likes anime porn? :D [/random babbling]
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:49 pm (UTC)I liked her first couple books as well (minus Interview, the movie of which i loved, but the book i hated), and Queen of the Damned was excellent, but i've never dared pick up anything later than that because they just sound...even reading the back makes them sound like tripe, i find.
lestat as a rock star is pretty effing hot. Lestat talking to the pope? uhm, hmm, perhaps i'll give that a pass.
no subject
Date: 2004-10-10 07:23 pm (UTC)My favorite was always Armand. It initiated me into the world of man/man action with the beautiful Marius/Armand scenes. Several years later and fully versed on man/man love, I confront other people who've read it with the scene and they dodge my questions and say 'I must have missed that part.' or 'I don't remember that in there.'
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:52 pm (UTC)...and it won't. In fact, the news article that was posted actually went in the opposite direction.
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:57 pm (UTC)And speaking of the Beauty trilogy, Tristan/Nicolas = OMG SO HAWT MY VERY FIRST SLASH OTP YAY HOORAY. When I first read those books (well, the first two--I was so disappointed at not getting more T/N that I never finished the third), I was a sheltered young thing who thought she'd personally invented ponyplay. The Marketplace series may be more realistic but it isn't anywhere near as sexy.
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 02:58 pm (UTC)(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:(no subject)
From:no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 03:23 pm (UTC)I loved Lestat in the early books.
Date: 2004-09-23 04:36 pm (UTC)mmm, cider....
Date: 2004-09-23 04:59 pm (UTC)But. Guido/Tonio. DED OF HOT even if any decent fanfic author would be laughed off LJ for attempting a no-lube first-time bottom scene like theirs. Emotional intensity yum yum yum.
Lestat, Louis loves you and always did. be nice to him.
::sighs::
Re: mmm, cider....
Date: 2004-09-28 07:29 pm (UTC)Besides, historically speaking, Crisco did not exist--anything that might serve as a safe and relatively clean lube was incredibly expensive (olive oils, cosmetic products like hand creams). I've always found it somewhat laugh-worthy when authors try to pull out Generic Lube Oil in fandoms like, oh, Pirates of the Caribbean, when it's highly unlikely from a historical standpoint that any such thing would exist. :D ((much amusement))
I never read beyond Interview, but... Lestat? Tom Cruise? Just--no.
Re: mmm, cider....
From:was a fan too
Date: 2004-09-23 05:52 pm (UTC)esp. the first 4 books (though 'The Vampire Lestat' & 'Queen of the Damned') were my favourite.
her work now seriously SERIOUSLY has gone down the drain. i don't even know why i bother to keep up with it. it's this strange affection you have for the older stuff that keeps you out looking and hoping that you might just get something worth your time.
i've also gone through the Witches trilogy and some of her other stuff. The Beauty series was HOT, and so very VERY smutty, heh. however, i've only read the first 2. if anyone has the softcopy of the third book, please email it to me. i'll be forever grateful. ^___^
l3stat@gmail.com
no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 06:57 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 09:59 pm (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-23 10:04 pm (UTC)And Beauty and the Captain with knife handle in the inn.
Oh, and Beauty with Mistress Lockley and Prince Richard in the bedchamber.
Heh, sounds like I'm playing Clue.
Tristin/Nicholas was hot, too. Especially when Nicholas teased Tristin into coming. Very hot.
I liked whiny Louis, though. He's my favorite character. But Interview isnt my favorite story, Queen of the Damned is. I stopped liking Anne Rice around the Tale of the Body Thief. Body swapping *rolls eyes* Just no. But I read Merrick and got even more annoyed. I hated what she did to Louis. I want to go back and read The Witching Hour, but I didn't really care for the Taltos storyline. But I think I need to reread the series.
no subject
Date: 2004-09-24 01:56 am (UTC)The "Beauty" books never did anything for me - I thought they were terribly boring...but I was reading Kyle Onstott's "Mandingo" series as a child (yeah, very permissive parents - no wonder I turned out as warped as I did.)
no subject
Date: 2004-09-24 03:03 am (UTC)no subject
Date: 2004-09-24 03:55 am (UTC)I too am a woobly Lestat fan. I liked Tale of the Body Thief too, but my favorite will always be Queen of the Damned (I <3 Khayman, and Baby Jenks). (and good god I'm surprised I made it through Interview) And god damnit, I haven't been able to get the first Mayfair Witches book, which is very annoying.
Are the Beauty books really that good? *wiggles eyebrows* I was always sort of apprehensive since when my sister said there were sexual acts involving cantelope. XD It just went wrong from there.