Oh, that explains so much! I saw the promo pic in a magazine, had my reaction, went googling for a promo pic online, thought, "Are those the same actors? Must be, I guess I'm just hallucinating," and then was extra-confused by blamebrampton's comment that the first season had been good, while I was thinking, "I thought the show had, like, just started?" Now I understand why I've been so confused!