Image from "If You Ask Me" article from EW Aug 31, 2012. (Which I still can't find online!)
Finally I found an online copy of the caricature that was used to accompany Libby Gelman-Waxner's Entertainment Weekly humor column touching on The Bourne Legacy, in which she praises Jeremy Renner's acting ability and in a roundabout way his looks:

( Full-size pic behind the cut )
Art by Kirsten Ulve. Left to right, Justin Theroux, Jennifer Aniston, Jeremy Renner, Rachel Weisz. Hel-lo, hatchmarked facial hair!
"Jeremy is also thuggishly sexy; he looks like Daniel Craig with the mumps."

( Full-size pic behind the cut )
Art by Kirsten Ulve. Left to right, Justin Theroux, Jennifer Aniston, Jeremy Renner, Rachel Weisz. Hel-lo, hatchmarked facial hair!